An Embarrassingly Poorly Reasoned Paper

by on November 8, 2007 · 4 comments

The Information Technology & Innovation Foundation, ordinarily the source of quality thinking, has produced an embarrassingly bad paper called Don’t Shoot the Messenger: Telecommunications Carriers Deserve Immunity for facilitating illegal wiretapping and surveillance.

Here’s a sampling of the kind of reasoning that pegged my b.s. detector:

[I]n its legislation to overhaul the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), Congress is poised to condone lawsuits against telecommunications carriers for complying with what they thought was a legal information-sharing program that was approved by the highest levels of government.

Previous post:

Next post: