Microsoft’s Bing Leads in Bringing Social Functionality to Search

by on September 3, 2009 · 13 comments

Microsoft is making a major push to integrate social networking tools like Facebook and Twitter into its Bing search engine: users will soon be able to “Ping” search results they like to their friends directly from Bing. Back in January, in “Google, the Innovator’s Dilemma and the Future of Search & Web Ads,” I talked about the implications of this history of search from the WSJ):

Microsoft missed its opportunities to get into paid search not because it was “dumb,” “uninnovative” or a “bad” company, but for the same sorts of reasons that big, highly successful and even particularly innovative companies fail.  The reasons companies generally succeed in mastering “adaptive” innovation of the technologies behind their established business models are the very reasons why such great companies struggle to encourage or channel the “disruptive” innovation that renders their core technologies and business models obsolete.  This dynamic was described brilliantly in Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen’s classic 1997 book The Innovator’s Dilemma:  When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail

Let’s hope that Microsoft—as well as Yahoo!—have carefully studied the vast literature produced by business schools in the wake of Christensen’s book about how big companies can avoid the Innovator’s Dilemma by promoting—and capitalizing on—radical innovation from within.  Indeed, this seems to be precisely what has guided Google’s own strategy as it has grown from “disruptive innovator” to become the very sort of behemoth that cannot easily escape the Dilemma, even if corporate managers are fully aware of the problem on a theoretical level.  If Google can do it, Microsoft should be able to, too.  But let’s also not discount the possibility that, no matter how hard Google’s management might try to retain the innovative culture of a start-up, the giant can’t do that well enough to prevent its own apparent market dominance from being disrupted by new upstart innovators in search and advertising technologies.

My prediction seems to be coming true: Microsoft, with less to lose and without a huge installed user base to worry about annoying by violating Google’s “Prime Directive” of elegant simplicity, may have an easier time introducing “disruptive” innovations to search than Google. Of course, it’s unlikely that any one feature will prove the “killer app” that suddenly causes Bing’s market share to explode—and Google’s to plummet—but a steady stream of such nifty features could convince many users to switch to Bing.

At 29, I’m old enough to remember when Microsoft seemed as cool as Google does today. Hell, I remember being thrilled as a sophomore in high school by Bill Gates’ 1995 book The Road Ahead and the accompanying CD-ROM (which included, as I recall, a tour of Gates’s ultra-futuristic home).  If Microsoft can “get its mojo back,” the company could truly become a web services provider to rival Google.  We’d all benefit from having more choices in search engines, advertising platforms and related tools. And, driving each other to “build a better mousetrap,” the two companies could lead us down the “Road Ahead” from Search 2.0 to Search 3.0 and beyond. So here’s to hoping that Redmond can solve the “Innovator’s Dilemma” with tools like Google’s “20 percent” time that free engineers to innovate!

  • Pingback: Retweet the Revolution: Help Spread the TLF’s Message on Twitter! — Technology Liberation Front

  • ronmorrison

    Great article – because it taught me something!
    It's great to hear too how Microsoft and other search engine companies are integrating social networking tools into search. What's so funny is that you can search Google for “social networks” and find no simple utility within Google to share what you found without going to the site(s) first. The consumers voice – our voice is definitely absent when it comes to search engines and their results. Generally what happens is you land on a page that the search engine found for you and that page/site is typically what you ended up “talking about” in your favorite social tool(s). ronsmap.com (no this not a shameless pitch) will be bringing that focus to it's search engine too. It's exactly where we're headed.
    As for me, I'm a bit older than 29 but it was great to see your comment about Gates' book: The Road Ahead. I remember reading it too. Even funnier is I looked at it on my book shelf just yesterday and thought that maybe I ought to re-read it considering that I was re-reading the Cluetrain Manifesto.

    Viva La Innovation!

  • http://www.ronsmap.com ronmorrison

    Great article – because it taught me something!
    It's great to hear too how Microsoft and other search engine companies are integrating social networking tools into search. What's so funny is that you can search Google for “social networks” and find no simple utility within Google to share what you found without going to the site(s) first. The consumers voice – our voice is definitely absent when it comes to search engines and their results. Generally what happens is you land on a page that the search engine found for you and that page/site is typically what you ended up “talking about” in your favorite social tool(s). ronsmap.com (no this not a shameless pitch) will be bringing that focus to it's search engine too. It's exactly where we're headed.
    As for me, I'm a bit older than 29 but it was great to see your comment about Gates' book: The Road Ahead. I remember reading it too. Even funnier is I looked at it on my book shelf just yesterday and thought that maybe I ought to re-read it considering that I was re-reading the Cluetrain Manifesto.

    Viva La Innovation!

  • http://www.ronsmap.com ronmorrison

    Great article – because it taught me something!
    It's great to hear too how Microsoft and other search engine companies are integrating social networking tools into search. What's so funny is that you can search Google for “social networks” and find no simple utility within Google to share what you found without going to the site(s) first. The consumers voice – our voice is definitely absent when it comes to search engines and their results. Generally what happens is you land on a page that the search engine found for you and that page/site is typically what you ended up “talking about” in your favorite social tool(s). ronsmap.com (no this not a shameless pitch) will be bringing that focus to it's search engine too. It's exactly where we're headed.
    As for me, I'm a bit older than 29 but it was great to see your comment about Gates' book: The Road Ahead. I remember reading it too. Even funnier is I looked at it on my book shelf just yesterday and thought that maybe I ought to re-read it considering that I was re-reading the Cluetrain Manifesto.

    Viva La Innovation!

  • Pingback: The Progress & Freedom Foundation Blog

  • Pingback: Social Advertising Is Just Around the Corner: Why A Facebook Ad Network Would Benefit Users — Technology Liberation Front

  • Pingback: porno izle

  • Pingback: 1300 phone number cost

  • Pingback: 1300 phone numbers

  • Pingback: garcinia cambogia

  • Pingback: prix de l'immobilier

  • Pingback: fantasy football

  • Pingback: see here

Previous post:

Next post: