Mike Palage: ICANN 3.0 Should “Refocus” on Original Purpose

PFF Adjunct Fellow Mike Palage, who served on the ICANN board from 2003 to 2006, filed these comments (PDF) on the NTIA’s recent Notice of Inquiry regarding ICANN’s future.  Mike’s four key points were as follows:

1. ICANN’s Periodic Review of its internal operations and supporting organizations has failed, and has become nothing more than a “perpetual motion machine of public comments and documentation producing no meaningful results.” Only a second Evolution and Reform Process can solve ICANN’s current deficiencies;
2. ICANN must hardcode into its policies and its contracts the principle that its policies cannot supersede national laws;
3. ICANN must cease any operational role in technical infrastructure as required by its bylaws and focus instead on its mission as a technical coordinator; and
4. Congress must avoid “kicking the JPA can down the road” and instead provide much-needed leadership by creating a solid foundation for ICANN 3.0 in legislation after proper consultation with the Government Accountability Office.

Tagged as: .com, .post, .tel, a root, accountability mechanisms, at large advisory committee, congress, country code name supporting organization, dennis carlton, department of commerce, evolution and reform process, gac, gao, government accountability office, government advisory committee, gtld, iana, ICANN, icann 2.0, icann 3.0, independent review, Internet Governance & ICANN, jpa, jpa/mou, kremen v. network solutions, legislation, marco lorenzo, mike palage, mou, Net, network solutions, NOI, ntia, palage, paul twomey, periodic review, PFF, private tldsupporting organization, Progress & Freedom Foundation, property clause, protocol supporting organization, PSO, public tldsupporting organization, registry, registry agreement, regulation, root l server, technical coordinator alac, telnic, thomas v. network solutions, U.S. Constitution, universal postal union, VeriSign, white paper

Comments Posted in: Internet Governance & ICANN, Trademark