New TLF Comment Tool (Please Read!)

by Berin Szoka on August 14, 2008 · Comments

Ahoy, TLFers!  You’ll notice that we’ve incorporated a new comment management system on the blog:  Pronounced “discuss” (not “discus” as one might well assume–a potential branding problem indeed for an otherwise promising start-up), Disqus has exploded in the last few months (Google Trends) to over 30,000 blogs.

Disqus should help the TLF become even more of a true community–in which comments can be as valuable as blog pieces themselves and in which the line between “reader” and “author” is further blurred.  Here’s a list of cool things Disqus will let you, TLF’s valued readers to do:

  • Track and manage comments and replies
  • More control over your own comments on websites
  • Never lose your comments, even if the website goes away
  • Build a global profile, or comment blog, to collect and show off what you’re saying
  • Easier to comment on websites using Disqus
  • Reply to comments through email or mobile
  • Edit and republish comments with one click

In particular, comments can now be directed as replies to other comments, creating clear discussion threads.

You might be wondering:  “If Disqus is so darn awesome, why haven’t we incorporated it before?”  The answer is that, until the new Disqus plug-in for WordPress came out a few days ago, comments were stored only on the Disqus site and merely replicated on partner blogs–making comments unsearchable, among other things.  Now, we get the best of both worlds:  Comments will beseemlessly duplicated and synchronized between our database and Disqus’s.

While it will still be possible to comment on the blog just as before (anonymously or merely without a Disqus account), we do encourage readers to take a minute (literally) to set up a free Disqus account.  (For those of you who enjoy reading Terms of Use and Privacy policies or who just stay up late at night clutching their now-constitutionally-protected firearms and worrying about being tagged, tracked and someday unceremoniously culled from the herd, here are Disqus’s policies.)  For the less privacy-obsessed, here’s a general FAQ about Discus.

There are a number of bells and whistles you can enable–like tying your Disqus account to other social networking sites and adding a small image of yourself (or some other hopefully-family-friendly image).  But the one important thing everyone who has posted comments in the past should do is to claim” your old comments by entering the email address associated with those comments on Disqus. (You’ll get a verification email at that address.)  We would particularly encourage other bloggers who read the TLF to consider adding Disqus to their own blogs to take full advantage of Disqus as a platform for carrying on discussions across multiple blogs.

Please let us know by commenting here if you notice any quirks about the conversion, such as comments not carrying over from the old system or comments you want to claim as your own but can’t.

Comments Posted in: Uncategorized

  • What did you guys have to do to get DISQUS to import your existing comments? I installed it on my personal blog and can't make that happen. I surmise that the "export comments to DISQUS" button on the Advanced Options is supposed to do something, but it just gives me a blank page.
  • Yup, I pressed that button and that's what did it. Took over half an hour to sync the over 12,000 comments here.
  • Did you get any feedback while that was happening? I just get a blank screen that says "done" but none of my 7,000 comments are imported.
  • Well, when it said "done" for me it really was done and everything had imported. Check out their support forum, they seem to be pretty responsive. http://disqus.disqus.com
  • Am I missing something or does that Disqus help forum not have a search feature? I want to search for a couple of things and can't find a search bar there.
  • Yeah, I can't believe it doesn't have search. I've been using Google
    to search just that site and it's coming up with all the right answers.
  • I've been contacted by the Disqus people about the problem I reported here with importing my comments. It's not resolved yet, but they're helping.

    Complaining about technology on TLF definitely gets results.

    BTW, I sure would like to get the side buttons working on my Microsoft Wireless Explorer mouse inside a Linux guest under Virtual Box. Anybody from Sun paying attention?
  • Ryan Radia
    Dugg for the new and vastly improved comment system (or should i say mod parent up?)
  • Type your comment here.
  • Ryan Radia
    Is it possible to edit or preview comments?
  • Good question! According to the Disqus support site, they're adding the ability to edit your own comment in the next few days. Looks like something they had rolled out but pulled back for some reason. As for previewing, looks like that's not an option, but the editing should obviate the need.
  • Ryan Radia
    Excellent.
  • Interesting post. Appreciate it as I have seen something new now.
    Can I use this info on my blog using the direct link to your blog? Thanks in advance
  • Yeah !
    It will build a global profile, or comment blog, to collect and show off what you’re saying........
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: