Comcast’s Cat and Mouse Game: 34,700 Mice

by on October 26, 2007 · 7 comments

One question that has been repeatedly raised in regards the the Comcast-BitTorrent affair is why wasn’t Comcast more open about what it was doing? Comcast’s response — supported by Richard Bennett in our recent podcast — is that more transparency would make it too easy to bypass the system. They say this is a cat-and-mouse game with bandwidth hogs (to mix zoological metaphors), and announcing what techniques are being used would simply give away the game.

That got me thinking. Since the Associated Press broke the story last week, the proverbial feline is pretty clearly out of the bag. Is word spreading on a bypass? A quick search on Google, with the phrase “how to bypass Comcast” indicates the answer is a resounding “yes,” with no less than 34,700 results. I’m not a technical expert, so I can’t say the bypasses work (and I freely admit I didn’t read all 34,700), but that’s still a lot of mice.

Of course, this doesn’t necessarily mean Comcast was right to keep its practices so hush-hush. Even if Comcast wasn’t under legal duties to reveal more, more transparency would certainly have precluded much of this week’s consumer outrage. Still, if the Google results are any gauge, the cat-and-mouse game does seem very real.

  • http://linuxworld.com/community/ Don Marti

    How many of the 34,000 “mice”, or “hogs,” are really getting throttled or zapped with forged RSTs, though, and how many are just people who happen to have Comcast service and think that their BitTorrent sessions are running too slow? Users might not be able to diagnose a problem, and will find it easy to blame Comcast for any slowness.

  • James Gattuso

    Check the post again. 34,700 is not a number of people, it is the number of Google results on “how to bypass Comcast.”

  • http://linuxworld.com/community/ Don Marti

    How many of the 34,000 “mice”, or “hogs,” are really getting throttled or zapped with forged RSTs, though, and how many are just people who happen to have Comcast service and think that their BitTorrent sessions are running too slow? Users might not be able to diagnose a problem, and will find it easy to blame Comcast for any slowness.

  • James Gattuso

    Check the post again. 34,700 is not a number of people, it is the number of Google results on “how to bypass Comcast.”

  • http://cuocthiseo.dreamhosters.com/ CuocThiseo

    Too much mice how can I…eat all of them?

  • http://dnlist.co.cc/ dnl

    Too much mice how can I…eat all of them?

  • http://dnlist.co.cc/ dnl

    Too much mice how can I…eat all of them?

Previous post:

Next post: