Free Lunches

by on June 19, 2006 · 102 comments

The Wall Street Journal has a write up of Craigslist, the online classified site that is steadily taking over the world. The author seems bewildered by the Craigslist phenomenon, seeming to think there must be some kind of trick or hidden agenda at work:

“The Internet at large, and free classifieds in particular–and even beyond that, Craigslist free classifieds in particular–certainly pose challenges to the newspaper industry as far as being able to raise their profitability over time.” Many in newspaper publishing would consider that an understatement. But Mr. Buckmaster is sanguine: “The demise of the newspaper has been overstated.” Phew. I expel a nervous chuckle of relief. In Mr. Buckmaster’s view, newspapers would be better off being a little more Craigslist-like: Go private, eschew Wall Street’s demands for continually “goosing profitability” and give your readers what they want. Much trouble in the world comes, in Mr. Buckmaster’s view, from losing sight of that essential goal.

After we’ve retired back to the living room for coffee, Mr. Buckmaster allows that the world is perhaps not quite that simple. When asked whether there’s a Craigslist model that other companies could emulate, the unflappable Mr. Buckmaster, his eyes once more fixed firmly on the horizon out the window, waxes lyrical for a moment: “It’s unrealistic to say, but–imagine our entire U.S. workforce deployed in units of 20. Each unit of 20 is running a business that tens of millions of people are getting enormous amounts of value out of each month. What kind of world would that be?”

Before I have time to object, Mr. Buckmaster comes back to our world. “Now, there’s something wrong in the reasoning there,” he admits. “You can’t run a steel company in the same way that you run an Internet company”–more points for understatement. “But still, it’s a nice kind of fantasy that there are more and more businesses where huge amounts of value can flow to the user for free. I like the idea, just as an end-user, of there being as many businesses like that as possible.” As an end-user, I suppose I do, too. But there are no free lunches, even if Craigslist–and the meal Mr. Buckmaster and Ms. Best provided for me–sometimes seem to come close.

The oft-repeated (especially by libertarians) view that there’s no such thing as a free lunch is actually nonsense. Civilization abounds in free lunches. Social cooperation produces immense surpluses that have allowed us to become as wealthy as we are. Craigslist is just an extreme example of this phenomenon, because it allows social cooperation on a much greater scale at radically reduced cost. Craigslist creates an enormous amount of surplus value (that is, the benefits to users vastly exceed the infrastructure costs of providing the service). For whatever reason, Craigslist itself has chosen to appropriate only a small portion of that value, leaving the vast majority to its users.


One way to look at this is to simply regard it as naivet© on the part of their management. But I don’t think that’s quite right. Consider this graph from Alexa:

That shows the relative traffic of Craigslist and the New York Times over the last 4 years. As you can see, in 2002, the New York Times had between five and ten times the traffic that Craigslist did (it’s hard to see exactly what CL’s number was). Today, they have about the same traffic. And there’s every reason to think Craigslist will continue to grow faster than the Times, as they’re nowhere near saturated in smaller markets.

If Alexa’s data went further back, we’d see equally impressive growth in the years between 1999 and 2002. What’s going on here, I think, is that the revenue forgone by Craigslist doesn’t simply disappear into the ether. The lack of ads and fees makes Craigslist a more pleasant website to use, which makes it possible for them to attract and retain users more effectively. In effect, they’re taking that surplus and investing it in user satisfaction rather than taking it as financial gains for themselves. That, in turn has a snowball effect: happier users tell their friends about you, and they, in turn, try the site and they too are happy.

This strategy is actually more common than the Wall Street Journal seems to think. Wikipedia is another example of a site that runs this way. (I’d show a Britannica vs. Wikipedia chart, but you can barely even see Britannica’s line in that chart) Another is LiveJournal, a site that until a couple of years ago was run primarily by volunteers and still makes 90 percent of its functionality available to users who never see an ad and don’t pay a dime. And of course, Google’s first advertisement didn’t appear until nearly 4 years after the site went public.

The strategy has another advantage too: charging people money for things is expensive. A significant fraction of the cost of a classified ad is the labor required to sell the ads. Even if you could automate that process, it’s still relatively expensive to process a credit card transaction. The same is true of ads. Which means that not only is Craigslist letting its users keep more of the surplus, but its surplus is actually bigger, too!

In the long run, then, I think sites that pursue a Craigslist-like strategy will come to dominate their categories, because they simply undercut their competition. That sucks if you’re the competitor, but it’s great for the rest of us!

  • mark

    We are accredited cell phones delear licensed and registered company. We sale in bulk and in units to private buyers and organization. we would be glad to respond to your inquiry as soon as possible.

    contact: tamaphoneinc@yahoo.com

    Nokia N95……..$300usd
    Nokia N93……..$250usd
    Nokia N90……..$180usd
    Nokia N91……..$200usd
    Nokia N92……..$220usd
    Nokia N71……..$155usd
    Nokia N70……..$150usd
    Nokia N80……..$210usd
    Nokia 7610…….$100usd
    Nokia 8800…….$140usd
    Nokia 9300…….$145usd
    Nokia 9500…….$170usd
    Nokia E60 …….$160usd
    Nokia E61 …….$180usd

    Samsung SGH i830 …..$220usd
    Samsung SGH D720 ….$170usd
    Samsung D500 …………$160usd

    Samsung i300 ………….$170usd
    Samsung K800i…………$180usd

    Sidekick 1………..$100usd
    Sidekick 2………..$120usd
    Sidekick 3………..$150usd

    Motorola razor v3……….$130usd
    Motorola razor v3 pink…$140usd
    Motorola v3x…………….$135usd

    Motorola MPX100………$120usd
    Motorola MPX300………$115usd

    Nextel i930……..$130usd
    Nextel 1960 ……$130usd
    Nextel i870……..$120usd
    Nextel i860……..$110usd

    Sony Ericsson W900i….$150usd
    Sony Ericsson W800i….$140usd
    Sony Ericsson w600i…..$138usd

    Treo 600……………$150usd
    Treo 650……………$160usd
    Treo 700w………….$200usd

    Play Station 1…….$100usd
    Play Station 2…….$140usd
    Xbox 360…………..$160usd

    Verizon/Motorola E815 EvDO for just $110
    Verizon/LG VX4500 Voice Recognition for just for $100
    Verizon’s World Phone for just $120
    Verizon/Motorola V265 for just $110
    Verizon XV6600 $130
    Verizon/Samsung SCH-a890 EVDO Handset $140
    Verizon CDM8940 3G EV-DO $140
    Verizon LG VX8000 EVDO $110
    Verizon/LG VX8100 $110
    Verizon/Samsung a950 $110

    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Blue M9802LL/A ……..$40.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Pink M9804LL/A ……. $40.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Green M9806LL/A …… $40.00
    Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Blue M9803LL/A ……. $45.00
    Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Silver M9801LL/A ….. $45.00
    Apple 20 GB iPod M9282LL/A…………….. $35.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Pink M9435LL/A ……. $35.00
    Apple 40 GB iPod photo …………………$35.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Silver M9160LL/A ….. $35.00
    Apple 30 GB iPod Photo M9829LL/A ………. $50.00
    Apple 512 MB iPod Shuffle MP3 Player M9724LL/A … $55.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Blue M9436LL/A ……..$45.00
    Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Green M9807LL/A……..$40.00
    Apple 20 GB iPod U2 Special Edition ……. $50.00
    Apple 60 GB iPod photo ………………. .$95.00
    Apple 60 GB iPod Photo M9830LL/A ………..$100.00
    Apple iPod 1GB Shuffle ……………….. $80
    Apple Ipod Nano 2GB ………………….. $90:00
    Apple Ipod Nano 4GB ……………………$100:00
    Ipod video 30GB……………………….$150
    Ipod video 60GB……………………….$200

    Sony Grand WEGA KDFE42A10 42 in LCD Rear-Projection TV ……….. $400
    Sony Grand WEGA SXRD KDS-R60XBR1 60 in Rear-Projection LCoS TV…..$600
    Sony Grand WEGA SXRD KDS-R50XBR1 50 in Rear-Projection LCoS TV … $450
    Sony Wega KDF-E50A10 50 in LCD Rear-Projection TV…………. $450
    Sharp Aquos LC-32DA5U 32 in Flat Panel LCD TV ………… $350
    Sony Wega KDL-V40XBR1 40 in Flat Panel LCD TV ……….. $400
    Sony Wega KD-36FS130 36 in Flat Screen TV …………… $400
    Samsung HL-R5067W 50 in Rear-Projection DLP TV ……… $450
    Panasonic TH-50PHD8UK 50 in Flat Panel Plasma TV………….. $500
    Samsung HL-R5667W 56 in Rear-Projection DLP TV ………….$500
    Samsung HL-R4266W 42 in Rear-Projection DLP TV ………… $450
    Samsung LN-R408D 40 in Flat Panel LCD TV …………. $400
    Samsung HP-R4252 42 in Flat Panel Plasma TV ………….. $450
    Magnavox 15MF605T 15 in Flat Panel LCD TV …………… $300
    Panasonic TH-42PWD8UK 42 in Flat Panel Plasma TV ………… $350
    Sony BRAVIA XBR KDL-V32XBR1 32 in Flat Panel LCD TV …… $350

    Email: tamaphoneinc@yahoo.com

  • mark

    We are accredited cell phones delear licensed and registered company. We sale in bulk and in units to private buyers and organization. we would be glad to respond to your inquiry as soon as possible.

    contact: tamaphoneinc@yahoo.com

    Nokia N95……..$300usd
    Nokia N93……..$250usd
    Nokia N90……..$180usd
    Nokia N91……..$200usd
    Nokia N92……..$220usd
    Nokia N71……..$155usd
    Nokia N70……..$150usd
    Nokia N80……..$210usd
    Nokia 7610…….$100usd
    Nokia 8800…….$140usd
    Nokia 9300…….$145usd
    Nokia 9500…….$170usd
    Nokia E60 …….$160usd
    Nokia E61 …….$180usd

    Samsung SGH i830 …..$220usd
    Samsung SGH D720 ….$170usd
    Samsung D500 …………$160usd

    Samsung i300 ………….$170usd
    Samsung K800i…………$180usd

    Sidekick 1………..$100usd
    Sidekick 2………..$120usd
    Sidekick 3………..$150usd

    Motorola razor v3……….$130usd
    Motorola razor v3 pink…$140usd
    Motorola v3x…………….$135usd

    Motorola MPX100………$120usd
    Motorola MPX300………$115usd

    Nextel i930……..$130usd
    Nextel 1960 ……$130usd
    Nextel i870……..$120usd
    Nextel i860……..$110usd

    Sony Ericsson W900i….$150usd
    Sony Ericsson W800i….$140usd
    Sony Ericsson w600i…..$138usd

    Treo 600……………$150usd
    Treo 650……………$160usd
    Treo 700w………….$200usd

    Play Station 1…….$100usd
    Play Station 2…….$140usd
    Xbox 360…………..$160usd

    Verizon/Motorola E815 EvDO for just $110
    Verizon/LG VX4500 Voice Recognition for just for $100
    Verizon’s World Phone for just $120
    Verizon/Motorola V265 for just $110
    Verizon XV6600 $130
    Verizon/Samsung SCH-a890 EVDO Handset $140
    Verizon CDM8940 3G EV-DO $140
    Verizon LG VX8000 EVDO $110
    Verizon/LG VX8100 $110
    Verizon/Samsung a950 $110

    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Blue M9802LL/A ……..$40.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Pink M9804LL/A ……. $40.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Green M9806LL/A …… $40.00
    Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Blue M9803LL/A ……. $45.00
    Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Silver M9801LL/A ….. $45.00
    Apple 20 GB iPod M9282LL/A…………….. $35.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Pink M9435LL/A ……. $35.00
    Apple 40 GB iPod photo …………………$35.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Silver M9160LL/A ….. $35.00
    Apple 30 GB iPod Photo M9829LL/A ………. $50.00
    Apple 512 MB iPod Shuffle MP3 Player M9724LL/A … $55.00
    Apple 4 GB iPod Mini Blue M9436LL/A ……..$45.00
    Apple 6 GB iPod Mini Green M9807LL/A……..$40.00
    Apple 20 GB iPod U2 Special Edition ……. $50.00
    Apple 60 GB iPod photo ………………. .$95.00
    Apple 60 GB iPod Photo M9830LL/A ………..$100.00
    Apple iPod 1GB Shuffle ……………….. $80
    Apple Ipod Nano 2GB ………………….. $90:00
    Apple Ipod Nano 4GB ……………………$100:00
    Ipod video 30GB……………………….$150
    Ipod video 60GB……………………….$200

    Sony Grand WEGA KDFE42A10 42 in LCD Rear-Projection TV ……….. $400
    Sony Grand WEGA SXRD KDS-R60XBR1 60 in Rear-Projection LCoS TV…..$600
    Sony Grand WEGA SXRD KDS-R50XBR1 50 in Rear-Projection LCoS TV … $450
    Sony Wega KDF-E50A10 50 in LCD Rear-Projection TV…………. $450
    Sharp Aquos LC-32DA5U 32 in Flat Panel LCD TV ………… $350
    Sony Wega KDL-V40XBR1 40 in Flat Panel LCD TV ……….. $400
    Sony Wega KD-36FS130 36 in Flat Screen TV …………… $400
    Samsung HL-R5067W 50 in Rear-Projection DLP TV ……… $450
    Panasonic TH-50PHD8UK 50 in Flat Panel Plasma TV………….. $500
    Samsung HL-R5667W 56 in Rear-Projection DLP TV ………….$500
    Samsung HL-R4266W 42 in Rear-Projection DLP TV ………… $450
    Samsung LN-R408D 40 in Flat Panel LCD TV …………. $400
    Samsung HP-R4252 42 in Flat Panel Plasma TV ………….. $450
    Magnavox 15MF605T 15 in Flat Panel LCD TV …………… $300
    Panasonic TH-42PWD8UK 42 in Flat Panel Plasma TV ………… $350
    Sony BRAVIA XBR KDL-V32XBR1 32 in Flat Panel LCD TV …… $350

    Email: tamaphoneinc@yahoo.com

Previous post:

Next post: